top of page

Let's Talk Finances: Should I apply for FAFSA if I know I won't qualify?

The cost of college education often exceeds the means of many families, making the decision to apply for need-based financial aid an apparent choice. However, navigating the complex and stressful landscape of financial aid can be daunting and fraught with potential pitfalls. This blog aims to offer a clear and concise guide to help families determine whether applying for need-based financial aid is the right choice for them. In addition, it will address who should apply for FAFSA and who should not apply, the potential advantages and disadvantages of demonstrating need, and essential factors to consider before proceeding with the application process. Read on to learn more!

A pink piggy bank sits upon a calculator.
Start saving those coins for college as early as you can!

Who Should Apply for FAFSA?

If you believe you might qualify for need-based aid, it is advisable to apply for it. To get an early estimation of your child's demonstrated need at the colleges they are interested in, you can use net price calculators available on each college's website.

Alternatively, the Big Future EFC Calculator can provide valuable insights.

Incoming freshmen who anticipate qualifying for need-based aid during their undergraduate years should consider applying for aid from the start. Some colleges may prioritize full-pay applicants during the admission process, and waiting to apply for aid in subsequent years may result in fewer opportunities for institutional aid. It is essential to plan for unforeseen financial circumstances and be prepared for worst-case scenarios.

Additionally, those hoping for merit-based scholarships should check each college's requirements to see if they need to submit the FAFSA or CSS Profile. While most institutions only require the college application itself, a few schools may request financial aid forms or specific scholarships might necessitate them.

Who Should Not Apply for FAFSA?

If the cost of the colleges your child is applying to is not a financial burden, and you are confident that there will be no significant financial hardships during their undergraduate years, there is no need to submit the FAFSA or CSS Profile.

Is There an Advantage to Not Applying for Financial Aid?

Yes, there can be advantages to not applying for financial aid. The application process for financial aid can be invasive and time-consuming. Additionally, colleges need full-pay students to support their financial stability. Opting not to apply for need-based financial aid can be advantageous for applicants, as it signals the college that they can afford the tuition and expenses.

However, it is important to note that this doesn't mean that full-pay applicants always receive an advantage over those with need. Colleges strive to admit the best possible freshman class each year, taking into account various factors beyond financial need.

Is There a Disadvantage to Demonstrating Need in the Application Process?

Occasionally, demonstrating significant need in the application process may have certain disadvantages. Colleges seek to enhance their profiles by considering multiple aspects, such as academic excellence, diversity, and athletic competitiveness. While financial need may be one of the factors, it might not always be advantageous during the final stages of building a class. In some cases, an applicant with moderate to substantial need might lose out to an applicant with no projected need.

Do Some States Require FAFSA Submission?

Yes, approximately a dozen states have enacted laws or are considering legislation that requires FAFSA submission. However, parents can choose to opt-out, and there is no obligation to submit the FAFSA to every college the student is applying to.

Important Factors to Consider Before Applying for Need-Based Aid:

The primary determinant of need eligibility is Adjusted Gross Income (AGI), found on line 11 of federal tax returns. Assets are the second most important factor considered. It is crucial to remember that the income considered is from two years prior to the student's enrollment year. For instance, if the student will begin college in August 2023, the FAFSA and CSS Profile will examine the tax year 2021.

Furthermore, there is no obligation to list all the colleges the student is applying to on the FAFSA and CSS Profile. Only the institutions for which the student seeks need-based aid should be included.

Overall, applying for need-based financial aid can be a crucial decision for many families, but it requires careful consideration of various factors.By understanding these aspects, families can make well-informed choices regarding financial aid for their child's college education.

If you need assistance in optimizing financial aid for your child in the form of scholarships, consider reaching out to us at today!


bottom of page